Sunday, January 5, 2014

Guest Post - Great-Grandmother's Oatmeal Cookies

Hi, everyone! I'm Joy. I blog at Yesterfood, which is about recipes and how cooking connects us to each other and to the past. I love recipes with a history or a story, and I can spend hours happily reading vintage recipes in old cookbooks.
I was so happy when Melissa invited me to guest post on her blog today, and I immediately thought of sharing these cookies with you. They represent what Yesterfood is all about, and the recipe came from a book I really enjoyed reading. Besides, who doesn't like to curl up with a good book, a cup or tea or coffee, and something delicious to nibble?

In 1988, the Daughters of the Republic of Texas gathered hundreds of old recipes from the early days of Texas and published them as A Pinch of This and a Handful of That. I have loved browsing through this  collection of pioneer recipes and household tips ("Clothes which have a bad odor may be wrapped up and buried for a day or two in the ground to remove the odor" and, "To heal chapped hands, rub them with buffalo tallow").
When I spotted this recipe, I knew I had to try it. These are definitely Great-Grandmother-worthy cookies...buttery and crisp around the edges, rich and chewy in the middle, and a perfect balance of raisins, pecans, and dough. I used old-fashioned oats in my cookies because that's probably what Great-Grandmother Tenery used: quick cooking oats were not developed until the 1920s.
Great-Grandmother Tenery's Oatmeal Cookies  Printable Recipe Navarro County, Texas, 1880 Ingredients: 1 cup butter, room temperature 2 cups sugar (I used 1 cup granulated sugar and 1 cup light brown sugar) 2 cups flour 1 teaspoon cinnamon 1 teaspoon baking soda 1 teaspoon baking powder 1/4 teaspoon salt (I added this- it was not in the original recipe) 1 tablespoon vanilla 2 large eggs 2 cups oatmeal 1 cup chopped pecans 1 cup raisins Here are the exact instructions, as written: "Cream butter and sugar, add eggs, one at a time and beat thoroughly. Sift dry ingredients three times and add to creamed mixture with oatmeal, pecans, and raisins. Drop on greased tins, and bake in moderate oven for 15 minutes". I added: Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Although the directions did not specify, I stirred the vanilla in right after the eggs. Bake on a parchment paper covered cookie sheet for 13 to 14 minutes or until just starting to brown (the longer they bake, the crispier they get). I dropped dough by rounded tablespoon-fulls. This made about 42 large (3.5"), delicious cookies.
Recipe from: Seconds of A Pinch of This and a Handful of That, 1830-1900 by The Daughters of the Republic of Texas. Post originally published on Yesterfood April 2013.
Thank you so much for joining me here today. I invite you to visit my blog, and to come and see me on any of your favorite social media:


Thanks so much for sharing this wonderful recipe Joy!
**You can also join Joy at the two Linky Parties that she co-hosts!


Treasure Box Tuesday starting Tuesday January 7th!

Sharing at these fun Parties!


  1. What a great post! The way you described these cookies is just like I remember my mom's oatmeal cookies turning out!!

    1. HI, Rosey! I'm so glad to see you- thanks for coming over here and reading my guest post! Happy New Year to you and yours! :)

  2. I love an old fashioned oatmeal cookie. These look scrumptious.

  3. Such a great post! These cookies look delicious! I'm a pinning mas woman so you know I pinned these scrumptious cookies. Thanks for sharing!

  4. Oh my! Those cookies look perfect! And I'm sure they are...Joy always has great recipes to share. I'm a cookie monster and my hubby loves oatmeal cookies...will be making these! Thanks to both of you for sharing!

    1. Marsha, you are wonderful! Thank you so much for coming by here and leaving a comment! ♥

  5. My hubby's all time favorite cookies, yum! Hugs

    1. Thank you so much for helping to make the Thursday Favorite Things blog hop so much fun Hugs!

  6. Oh these are fave in our home. Now I have a recipe!

  7. Definitely adding these to the must bake cookie list!

  8. These look delicious! I always love old family recipes.

    Thank you for stopping by All Natural Katie!

  9. Melissa, you have the BEST friends! ♥ Thanks for all your wonderful comments, everyone!


I love comments, thanks so much for stopping by!

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Favorite Quilting Blogs

  • Some of This; Some of That - Free fat quarter giveaway still open. See top, sidebar. My stash report: .05 for last RSC block this month; .6 for border on Spontaneous Construction; ....
    1 hour ago
  • Oh Scrap! : More Blocks for Sampler - I was able to spend a bit of time yesterday sewing up a few more blocks for my Splendid Sampler quilt. At this point, I have sewn almost all of the true S...
    6 hours ago
  • Hexies - I didn’t touch the Star quilt yesterday. I thought I would give it a day or two thinking about binding and I needed a break from the sewing machine! Than...
    11 hours ago
  • Paint Chip Mini Quilt - We shared this mini quilt in a presentation at QuiltCon and promised attendees that they could find the tutorial on the blog. We first posted it about a ye...
    13 hours ago
  • Sew Sweet Bee February - Happy Monday sweet friends! Today has been a rainy day. The yard is so soggy we can not even walk in it. Hope you are staying dry? This month's Queen ...
    5 days ago
  • Bella Skils Builder - Welcome!! Over the next few months, until November exactly, I'll be participating in the Bella Skill Builder QAL with Fat Quarter Shop! And you should too...
    3 weeks ago
  • Burgoyne Blossoms - [image: quilts for foster kids, charity quilts, quanket] Burgoyne Blossoms is a Burgoyne Surrounded quilt pattern. I have been wanting to try this pattern...
    2 months ago
  • hi. - hi. i have tried several times to write this post. sometimes, i hit the backspace button so often, it's all the more discouraging. today, i feel like it'...
    6 months ago
  • Visit us at our new home - This is our final post to this address. Please bookmark our blog at its new home. The Quilt Alliance is pleased to announce the launch of our new website!...
    11 months ago